Comments by

Emily Koballa

Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 16

I like how the camera distances change once the cannon is shot (which is shown from far away). The drums sound so sporatic and spazzy that it makes the audience tense, and helps the mood of the scene. You can really feel how anxious Peyton is to get away.

go to thread »
Posted October 9, 2007  11:14 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 8

I like how the slow motion of the soldiers contrasts to how fast the situation probably went in real life. However, all of this seemed to be from Peyton’s point of view, especially when it was a close up on is eye.

go to thread »
Posted October 9, 2007  11:09 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 4

This music, although a little annoying to me, shows that the realization of what has just happened. Peyton sees that he has escaped death and notices all the small things around him. The music is also adds to the scene because the singer is singing about a living man.

go to thread »
Posted October 9, 2007  10:55 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 2

You can really see the agony he is going through trying to struggle out of his restraints. It’s also very ominous with the whole scene being in the water and the only sounds of the water moving. It fits with the story though, because the author never mentions what is happening above the water, and the audience never sees what happens either.

go to thread »
Posted October 9, 2007  10:44 pm
Part 1: "A man stood upon a railroad bridge in northern Alabama...", paragraph 6

I like the contrast between the fast annoying ticking of the watch and the slow motion moving of Peyton’s wife.

go to thread »
Posted October 9, 2007  10:36 pm
Part 1: "A man stood upon a railroad bridge in northern Alabama...", paragraph 2

I think the fact that none of the men talk at all shows that they really don’t like their job or at least this part of it. Or maybe they just take it so seriously. They just seem like they are going through the motions.

go to thread »
Posted October 9, 2007  10:31 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 14, replying to Rachel Shocket

That makes a lot more sense now, it adds to the story a lot knowing that.

Aeolus was the Greek god of wind. Here, "Aelolian harps" acts as both auditory imagery and a mythical allusion. It also reinforces how majestic the "enchanted spot" was for Farquhar.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  1:09 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 14

I like how he describes the ground as diamonds and rubies, it makes him seem more desperate, and gives it a more urgent and dangerous sense.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  1:05 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 12

I like how he used the contrast of the meaning of the word diminuendo and putting it in caps to make it noticeable.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  1:02 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 5

Why do they call bullets “reports”? At least, i think that’s what it means.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  1:01 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 2

The way that he talks to himself is interesting to me, encouraging himself like that. I don’t think many people talk like that to themselves.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  1:00 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 1

He describes this pain with so much description, that it kind of scared me. Like, maybe it was close to home for the author or something.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  12:59 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 20

This part was confusing because i’m not sure if you really needed part II then. it also seems a bit morbid for the overall story.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  12:58 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 7

I think there should have been more action in here. It would have been stronger with more than words.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  12:57 pm
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 10

I like how he used “hunted man” as synonymous to Peyton, to show how cruel this whole scene was. I agree that it does make him sound like an animal.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:45 am
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 5

I have never heard that men with gray eyes were the keenest, and it does seem silly that at first, every man looks horrible and grotesque and now he can see their eye color.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:42 am
Part 3: "As Peyton Farquhar fell straight downward...", paragraph 4

I like how he just notices that all the men are shouting and realizing that he is still alive. I wonder what was going on above the surface while Peyton was underwater.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:40 am
Part 2: "Peyton Farquhar was a well to do planter. . . .", paragraph 5

I think it’s strange that he is going to be hung on the same bridge that he wanted to burn down. I guess they didn’t have a better place to do it?

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:34 am
Part 2: "Peyton Farquhar was a well to do planter. . . .", paragraph 5, replying to Rachel Shocket

Yeah, I totally missed that the first time I read it too, but it makes the readers want to keep reading past part I to figure out what exactly he did.

This is a clever way of informing the reader why Farquhar was being hanged at the beginning of the story. Instead of telling us outright, the reason is hidden in Part II of the story.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:33 am
Part 2: "Peyton Farquhar was a well to do planter. . . .", paragraph 4, replying to Jordan Johnson

As soon as he asks how far Owl Creek bridge is, the man knows that he has Peyton trapped, which is sad. I think Peyton was far too eager for his own good. It makes me wonder why he wasn’t out with the other men fighting.

For those who don't know, a sentinel is just a soldier who watches over a certain area. The fact that he points out a SINGLE sentinel just makes it more obvious that he's setting him up.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:31 am
Part 2: "Peyton Farquhar was a well to do planter. . . .", paragraph 2, replying to Rachel Shocket

See, that part of the sentence bugs me though, even though it is set in to show people’s thoughts at the time because it was the South during the war. It seems out of place and like the author is trying to mock Mrs. Farquhar for being that way.

I think the most interesting phrase in this paragraph is that Mrs. Farquhar served the soldier with "her own white hands". Oftentimes color imagery is used in stories to act as imagery (white = purity), but here I think it shows that the South was so important to the Farquhars, and the soldier so respected, that any old slave wasn't worthy to serve him... Mrs. Farquhar reserved that honor for herself.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:27 am
Part 1: "A man stood upon a railroad bridge in northern Alabama...", paragraph 7, replying to Lacy Green

I also agree, most readers would realize that this was all racing through his head and not being said or thought out loud. The author probably wanted as little emotion as possible when changing to part II, which talks about his life.

I agree Daniel. Compared to the strange set up of the rest of the story, this sentence comes off as completely obvious and unnecessary. It really doesn't structurally mirror the rest of the story, but perhaps that was the authors intent.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:22 am
Part 1: "A man stood upon a railroad bridge in northern Alabama...", paragraph 4

It is interesting to me that he would be so easily distracted when he is about to be hung. It seems like he is almost distracting himself on purpose to get his mind off of what is about to happen.

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:16 am
Part 1: "A man stood upon a railroad bridge in northern Alabama...", paragraph 3

This kinda makes me curious as to exactly why he is being hung, if he was “no vulgar assassin.”

go to thread »
Posted October 8, 2007  10:12 am
Part 1: "A man stood upon a railroad bridge in northern Alabama...", paragraph 1

I think that the wording and sentence structure is also very awkward, which adds to the overall awkwardness of the situation.

go to thread »
Posted October 3, 2007  11:02 pm